GACUS Umpire assessment

This form is for feedback to GACUS on umpires appointed to games - normally only Division 1. GACUS greatly appreciates this feedback, so that it can continually monitor the performance of the appointed umpires
To be completed by the HOME team (unless the captains agree otherwise)
The home and away captains are asked to agree a balanced and objective assesment of the umpires' performance.
Match date:
Division:
Home team:
Away team:
First umpire name:
Quality of decision making:
A - Excellent and consistent   C - Below average to unsatisfactory  
B - Reasonable and confidently made    D - Poor to unacceptable  
Please comment if mark is C or D
Application of law and playing regulations:
A - Excellent and consistent   C - Below average  
B - Reasonably consistent and fair    D - Loose and inconsistent  
Please comment if mark is C or D
Coping with pressure:
Amount of pressure during the game
Heavy   Above Average   Average   Slight / none  
Coping with the pressure:
A - Firm and correctly handled   C - Below average  
B - Reasonable and fairly handled   D - Flustered and poorly handled  
Please comment if mark is C or D
Overall performance troughout the match:
A - Excellent control with confidence   C - Below average to poor  
B - Reasonable control with confidence   D - To poor to be acceptable  
Please comment if mark is C or D
From prior performances and this match, would you recommend this umpire to officiate in a higher level match?
Yes definitely   Yes probably   Probably not   Definitely not  
 
Second umpire name:
Quality of decision making:
A - Excellent and consistent   C - Below average to unsatisfactory  
B - Reasonable and confidently made    D - Poor to unacceptable  
Please comment if mark is C or D
Application of law and playing regulations:
A - Excellent and consistent   C - Below average  
B - Reasonably consistent and fair    D - Loose and inconsistent  
Please comment if mark is C or D
Coping with pressure:
Amount of pressure during the game
Heavy   Above Average   Average   Slight / none  
Coping with the pressure:
A - Firm and correctly handled   C - Below average  
B - Reasonable and fairly handled   D - Flustered and poorly handled  
Please comment if mark is C or D
Overall performance troughout the match:
A - Excellent control with confidence   C - Below average to poor  
B - Reasonable control with confidence   D - To poor to be acceptable  
Please comment if mark is C or D
From prior performances and this match, would you recommend this umpire to officiate in a higher level match?
Yes definitely   Yes probably   Probably not   Definitely not  

Captains and umpires should meet before the game to discuss and agree arrangements, check team sheets, talk about discipline etc.
Captains and umpires should meet after the game to give feedback to each other and talk over problems that arose.

Discussions before and after the game:
Captains and umpires met before the game   Did not meet before the game  
Any comment on the pre-match meeting
Captains and umpires met after the game   Did not meet after the game  
Any comment on the post-match meeting.
In particular can you note what feedback was given to each umpire about their performance
Sender name:
E-mail address:  for a copy / receipt for your records
Club keycolour: